"But whatever (the state Constitution) means, it surely cannot be that each qualified elector can undertake his orher own separate audit of an election.". In 2014, Edwardss family filed a request under, Justia Opinion Summary: Robert Taylor was convicted by jury of first degree felony murder, carjacking, conspiracy to commit carjacking, kidnapping conspiracy to commit kidnapping, and possession of a firearm during the commission of a felony., Justia Opinion Summary: In case no. [28] The Court also noted national trends in state courts towards extending Miller beyond the mandatory life without parole context. Despite numerous experts highlighting obvious flaws in the report, Trump used it to try and bolster his efforts to undermine the 2020 election results. Right-wing Christian activists sought to work their way into the social circles of conservative-leaning U.S. Supreme Court justices offering prayers, meals, "warm personal greetings," and Decision 2022 Published: October 31, 2022, 9:37 AM Tags: Michigan Election Results , Michigan Supreme Court , Michigan General Election 2022 , Michigan Elections , Election Results , 2022 Elections [32], In Promote the Vote 2022 v. Board of State Canvassers, the Court ordered an initiated proposal concerning voting rights to be placed on the ballot after the Board of State Canvassers again deadlocked on whether to certify the measure. Judge dismisses charges against former Gov. at *20-28 (Zahra, J. dissenting), *29 (Viviano, J. dissenting). [14] Rouch World, LLC. DePerno and his lawsuit gained national attention as he rode the wave of election criticism and denial after President Donald Trump lost in 2020. Schenck's story," Chairman Jerry Nadler told his committee. The Michigan Supreme Court will not be liable for any damages whatsoever resulting from the use of or in connection with this website. The amendment bars any officers and members of the governing bodies of national, state and local political parties, as well as precinct delegates for political parties, from playing any role in the direction, supervision, or conduct of an election audit.. Muskegon County Prosecutor DJ Hilson, a Democrat with more than 20 years of experience, was appointed to take over the case in September. Each justice serves an eight-year term. Follow him on Twitter @Dave_Boucher1. This site was built using the UW Theme | Privacy Notice | 2022 Board of Regents of the University of Wisconsin System. [29], Finally, in People v. Boykin; People v. Tate, the Court considered the proper way to account for a juvenile offenders youth in the special sentencing process when the prosecution seeks a sentence to a term of years (rather than life with or without parole). September 22, 2022 First-of-its-kind Galleri Multi-Cancer Early Detection blood test can screen for multiple cancers through a single blood draw. Department of Civil Rights, __ Mich. __, __ N.W.2d __, 2022 WL 3007805 (2022). [20] That question may well be the subject of further litigation in the near future. [26] The Court, in a 4-3, party-line decision written by Chief Justice McCormack, acknowledged that Miller and Montgomery allow for parolable life sentences for juvenile offenders as a matter of federal Eighth Amendment law but held that the Michigan Constitutions ban on cruel or unusual punishment prohibits such a sentence. 91.7 Ann Arbor/Detroit 104.1 Grand Rapids FLINT, Mich. A judge dismissed criminal charges against former Michigan Gov. Only judges in lower courts may be removed in this manner. WebThe Michigan Supreme Court provides these links solely for user information and convenience, and not as endorsements of the products, services or views expressed. "I believe we pushed the boundaries of Christian ethics and compromised the high court's promise to administer equal justice.". DePerno, endorsed by Trump, became the Republican nominee for Michigan Attorney General but lost last month to incumbent Dana Nessel by 9 percentage points. Grant Faint/Getty Images. [24] People v. Parks, __ Mich. __, __ N.W.2d __, 2022 WL 3008548 (2022). The Michigan Supreme Court ordered Thursday that a citizen-initiative ballot measure seeking to enshrine abortion rights in the state constitution be added to the The opinions published on Justia State Caselaw are sourced from individual, People Of Mi V Joshun Edwards (Opinion on Application - Remand to TC), Michigan v. Hinton (Opinion on Application - Remand to TC), Michigan v. Taylor (Opinion on Application - Remand to CoA), Michigan v. Boykin (Opinion on Application - Remand to CoA), People Of Mi V Tyler Maurice Tate (Opinion on Application - Remand to CoA), Michigan v. Parks (Opinion on Application - Remand to TC), Michigan v. Stovall (Opinion - Leave Granted), Rouch World LLC v. Department Of Civil Rights (Opinion - Leave Granted), Jordan v. Dept. 0:03. They worked to bolster the justices' conservative views on issues including abortion and same-sex marriage, he said, sometimes achieving a rare level of access and intimacy with the judges. Among the cases waiting for oral argument to be scheduled is Joshua Wade v. University of Michigan, which involves a claim that the University of Michigans prohibition of firearms on its campus violates the state and federal constitutions. To see more, visit https://www.npr.org. Afterward, Schenck said, the donor told him she'd learned there that the decision in Burwell v. Hobby Lobby, a case before the court that centered on religious liberty, would be favorable to conservatives. Users acknowledge During a recess on the second day of the trial, the mother of the victims child made, Justia Opinion Summary: Donald Davis was convicted by jury on multiple felonies relating to the shooting death of Devante Hanson. "Throughout this ordeal, I've had to look deeply at what my cohorts and I did at the Supreme Court," Rev. And in Detroit Caucus, the Court issued an order that rejected claims by a group of Black members of the Michigan Legislature that the state legislative and congressional maps violated the Voting Rights Act; this was a 4-3 decision with two Republican Party-nominated Justices (Zahra and Viviano) and one Democratic Party-nominated Justice (Bernstein) in the dissent. Earlier this year, the office of the attorney general revealed the existence of a criminal investigation that alleges DePerno and others illegally gained access to and tampered with voting machines from small, northern Michigan communities not in Antrim County. In addition to whatever action Congress might take, Justice Roberts also has ordered an internal investigation into the source of the Dobbs leak in. Lawmakers say we'll find out next year. That subsidiary assigned the, Justia Opinion Summary: Consumers Energy Company filed an action against Brian and Erin Storm, and Lake Michigan Credit Union, seeking to condemn a portion of the Storms property for a power-line easement. The JTC, Justia Opinion Summary: The Judicial Tenure Commission (JTC) filed a formal three-count complaint against Third Circuit Court Judge Bruce Morrow, arising from comments he made to two female prosecutors during a murder trial. Nov. 13, 2015). COA: 324157 . That year, Chief Justice Bridget Mary McCormack was re-elected to the Court and Justice Elizabeth Welch was elected, creating a 4-3 majority of Justices who had been nominated by the Democratic Partythe Courts first Democratic majority in nearly a decade. 1, 905 N.W.2d 439 (2017). The opinions published on Justia State Caselaw are sourced from individual, People Of Mi V Joshun Edwards (Opinion on Application - Remand to TC), Michigan v. Hinton (Opinion on Application - Remand to TC), Michigan v. Taylor (Opinion on Application - Remand to CoA), Michigan v. Boykin (Opinion on Application - Remand to CoA), People Of Mi V Tyler Maurice Tate (Opinion on Application - Remand to CoA), Michigan v. Parks (Opinion on Application - Remand to TC), Michigan v. Stovall (Opinion - Leave Granted), Rouch World LLC v. Department Of Civil Rights (Opinion - Leave Granted), Jordan v. Dept. at *9 citing Godfrey v. Iowa, 898 N.W.2d 844, 856-857 (Iowa 2017). Michigan was one of 30 states that held elections for state supreme court in 2022. decisions from the Michigan Court of Appeals, Michigan appeals court rules against DePerno effort to revive debunked election fraud case, Judge dismisses Antrim County election fraud lawsuit, Prosecutor: DePerno criminal investigation won't be done before Election Day, Muskegon prosecutor appointed to review criminal allegations against DePerno, others, Your California Privacy Rights / Privacy Policy. . [25], In People v. Stovall, the Court weighed the constitutionality of a sentence of life with the possibility of parole for a defendant who committed second-degree murder while a juvenile. Secretary of State Jocelyn Benson said in a statement the Supreme Courts rejection further affirms the 2020 election was fair, secure and accurate., Suggestions to the contrary are misguided, Benson said, and meritless attempts to undermine the integrity of elections and harm American democracy.. [37] In re Executive Message (Governor v. Prosecuting Attorneys) (Mich. Supreme Court Docket No. The impact of the shift in the partisan composition of the Court is seen in the Courts more contentious decisionsthose decided by 4-3 or 5-2 votes where a difference in the composition of the Court likely would have resulted in a different outcome. FILE - Mildred Loving and her husband Richard P Loving are seen on Jan. 26, 1965. Stovall argued that his sentence was cruel and/or unusual punishment under both the United States and Michigan, Justia Opinion Summary: Rouch World, LLC, and Uprooted Electrolysis, LLC, brought an action before the Michigan Court of Claims against the Department of Civil Rights and its director, seeking, among other relief, a declaratory judgment that, Justia Opinion Summary: Helen Jordan, a nurse who was formerly employed by the predecessor to the Michigan Department of Health and Human Services, challenged in the Michigan Compensation Appellate Commission (MCAC) the decision of a magistrate, Justia Opinion Summary: In 2016, defendant James Beck was charged relating to allegations that he sexually assaulted his minor daughter, TG (first-degree criminal sexual conduct (CSC-I), and three counts of second-degree criminal sexual conduct, Justia Opinion Summary: Grant Bauserman, Karl Williams, and Teddy Broe, on behalf of themselves and all others similarly situated, brought a putative class action in the Michigan Court of Claims against the Unemployment Insurance Agency,, Justia Opinion Summary: David Lucynski was charged with operating a vehicle while intoxicated (OWI); driving with a suspended license; and operating a vehicle with an open container of alcohol in the vehicle. It is responsible for interpreting the Constitution of the United States. WebLANSING The Michigan Supreme Court declined to hear an Antrim County election-related lawsuit, thus upholding previous dismissal decisions by the state Court of Appeals and a lower court, in a case that garnered national headlines and In May 2022, the Court of Claims issued a preliminary injunction that temporarily blocked the Michigan Attorney General and all local officials acting under the [Attorney Generals] supervision from enforcing the ban. Although he lost by 9 percentage points to Michigan Attorney General Dana Nessel, he's now running to become the next chairman of the Michigan Republican Party. Please refer tothe Pending and Resolved Formal Proceedings (accessible on the Home Page)for an alphabetical list of disciplinary proceedings by judicial officers'last names. The Court, in a 4-3, party-line decision written by Justice Welch, the Court held that the U.S. Supreme Courts logic in Miller about why children are different from adults for purposes of sentencing also applied to 18-year-olds and concluded that mandatory life sentences for 18-year-olds constitute cruel or unusual punishment in violation of the Michigan Constitution. In an earlier version of this story, we misspelled Rev. of Michigan Supreme Court opinions. On appeal, the Court of Appeals ruled that the Court of Claims decision did not apply to county prosecutors. The Supreme Court already has pending a request from Governor Whitmer to authorize a county circuit court to certify to the Supreme Court the questions of whether the abortion ban violates the Due Process and Equal Protection Clauses of the Michigan Constitution, and whether the Michigan Constitution guarantees the right to abortion. PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF MICHIGAN v. LANTZ HOWARD WASHINGTON. 164191) were charged with various offenses for actions they took as state employees during the Flint water crisis. Because the Boards tie vote would have kept the proposal off the ballot,[31] supporters of the proposal sought expedited review in the Michigan Supreme Court. Justia Opinion Summary: Kino Christian, Joshun Edwards, and CQuan Hinton were convicted by jury of murder in 2007 and sentenced to life in prison. Barry Winiker/Getty Images. December 1, 2022. In 2014, Edwardss family filed a request under, Justia Opinion Summary: Robert Taylor was convicted by jury of first degree felony murder, carjacking, conspiracy to commit carjacking, kidnapping conspiracy to commit kidnapping, and possession of a firearm during the commission of a felony., Justia Opinion Summary: In case no. MERC Decisions Pending Before the Michigan Supreme Court. In recent years, Schenck has said publicly that his political views have changed significantly and that he now opposes what he calls "extreme" restrictions on abortion. Final reported versions of decisions cannot be provided, but links to the opinions as originally issued by the Supreme Court are included from 2010 through the present. Kent CC: 10-002810-FC . [38] The Supreme Court also has a pending request from the same matter filed by the Michigan Catholic Conference, Right to Life Michigan, and two county prosecutors. Schenck said that in 2014, a donor to his organization had dined at the home of Justice Samuel Alito. The Court, in a 5-2 order (with Justices Zahra and Viviano dissenting), rejected the opponents spacing argument, explaining that state law does not specify a certain amount of spacing in the text and that the petition complied with all existing requirements. The Court rejected the event space owners argument in a 5-2 opinion written by Justice Clement and joined by the four Democratic-nominated Justices. Nos. The Michigan Supreme Court provides these links solely for user information and convenience, and not as endorsements of the products, services or views expressed. Democrats have proposed legislation that would impose a code of ethics on the justices, but so far have been unable to pass it. Defendants direct appeals were unsuccessful. A Michigan Supreme Court order denied DePernos final appeal after a state appeals court and a lower court dismissed the suit: (W)e are not persuaded that the Justia Opinion Summary: Kino Christian, Joshun Edwards, and CQuan Hinton were convicted by jury of murder in 2007 and sentenced to life in prison. To serve on the Michigan Supreme Court, a candidate must be younger than 70, which is the mandatory retirement age in Michigan. Following the Courts decisions in Reproductive Freedom For All and Promote the Vote 2022, the Board of State Canvassers met and certified the proposed constitutional amendments for placement on the November 8, 2022 general election ballot. He did argue that a portion of the Michigan Constitution updated by a 2018 voting amendment that deals with audits could be clarified, though. [10] Bauserman v. Unemployment Insurance Agency, __ Mich. __, __ N.W.2d __, 2022 WL 2965921 (2022). [8] In contrast, the Court concluded that the burden imposed by the checkbox requirement was sufficiently minimal that the governmental interest in increasing information for voters served as an adequate justification. In these decisions, the four Democratic-nominated Justices usually voted together and were occasionally joined by Republican-nominated Justice Elizabeth Clement. In other cases, the Governor may remove a justice from the Court based on a concurrent resolution by two-thirds of the members of both the House of Representatives and the Senate. The, Justia Opinion Summary: James Township, Michigan filed a nuisance action against Daniel Rice , alleging Rice violated the townships blight ordinance as well as the Michigan Residential Code by having junk cars, unpermitted construction, and, Justia Opinion Summary: Meemic Insurance Company filed a subrogation claim against Angela Jones, seeking to recover from Jones money it had paid to CitiMortgage, Inc., the mortgagee of a residential house owned by Jones and insured by Meemic,, Justia Opinion Summary: When a party files an action for divorce and the other spouse subsequently dies before the divorce is finalized, there is a rebuttable presumption that the surviving spouse was not willfully absent from the decedent, Justia Opinion Summary: Mecosta County Medical Center, d/b/a Spectrum Health Big Rapids (and others) sued Metropolitan Group Property and Casualty Insurance Company and State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company at the Kent Circuit Court,, Justia Opinion Summary: John Moss was convicted of third-degree criminal sexual conduct (CSC-III) after he pleaded no contest to the charge. The procedures had been adopted by the Michigan Legislature following two U.S. Supreme Court decisions: Miller v. Alabama (2012),[21] which held that sentencing an individual to mandatory life without parole for a crime they committed before they were 18 violates the Eighth Amendments ban on cruel and unusual punishments, and Montgomery v. Louisiana (2016),[22] which held that Miller applied retroactively to people who had already been sentenced under mandatory life without parole laws. of Health & Human Servs. In contrast to many states, a justice on the Michigan Supreme Court may not be removed based on a recommendation by the Judicial Tenure Commission. In addition, the Court has scheduled 11 cases for oral arguments in October and has another 50 cases waiting to be scheduled, including a challenge to the University of Michigans prohibition of firearms on its campus. [43] The oral argument has not yet been rescheduled, but given that the Court tried to hold the argument twice last term, it seems likely that the Court will again seek to do this term. Michigan v. Hinton (Opinion on Application - Remand to TC) Date: August 16, 2022 Docket Numbers: 162374, 162355, 162354 Justia Opinion Summary: Kino Christian, Joshun Edwards, and CQuan Hinton were convicted by jury of murder in 2007 and sentenced to Zachary Clingenpeel | ZClingenpeel@mlive.com, News never stops. While the order does not provide a lengthy description of why the appeal was denied, Justice David Viviano offered some context for why he thought the appeal was not warranted. Michigan Supreme Court issued an opinion addressing a judicial disciplinary matter,after formal proceedings or based on a judicial officer's consent,in the following cases. Citing the U.S. Supreme Courts ruling in Bostock v. Clayton Co. (2020), which analyzed a similar provision in Title VII of the federal Civil Rights Act,[17] the Court explained that because ones gender is necessary to the identification of ones sexual orientation, discrimination on the basis of sexual orientation necessarily requires the discriminator to treat individuals differently because of their gender. (The Courts seven Justices are officially nonpartisan, but they must be nominated by a political party to appear on a general election ballot.). The Michigan Supreme Court issued an opinion addressing a judicial disciplinary matter,after formal proceedings or based on a judicial officer's consent,in the following cases. Some watchdog groups would like to see the court adopt an ethics code for the justices. Plaintiff, the American Civil Liberties Union of Michigan (the ACLU), submitted a FOIA request to defendant, the Calhoun, Justia Opinion Summary: Jeremiah and his wife Micheline Leffew, were convicted by jury trial in the for first-degree home invasion and third-degree home invasion. Today the Michigan Supreme Court affirmed what the people of Michigan made clear they knew when they voted in record numbers in the recent midterm election that the 2020 election was fair, secure and accurate and suggestions to the contrary are misguided, and meritless attempts to undermine the integrity of elections and harm American democracy," Benson said in a statement. They argued that sex, as used in the ELCRA, is limited strictly to gender. In this case, the plaintiffs sought to vindicate their state constitutional right to due process: They (along with an estimated 40,000 others in Michigan) had sought unemployment compensation benefits from Michigans Unemployment Insurance Agency, but an automated computer system erroneously found them to have committed fraud. WebI, Larry S. Royster, Clerk of the Michigan Supreme Court, certify that the foregoing is a true and complete copy of the order entered at the direction of the Court. But he may face criminal charges before that election. "The precise contours of this new audit right are unclear and have never been addressed by this court. 163667), Richard Baird (Docket No. December 7, 2022 Political News. Dec. 10 (UPI) -- Michigan prosecutors say they will appeal a court decision dismissing charges against former Gov. For the 2021-2022 term, this amounted to 39 published opinions. (Opinion on Application - Remand to TC), Michigan v. Beck (Opinion on Application - Partial Affirm), People Of Mi V Kino Dominque Christian (Opinion on Application - Remand to TC), Bauserman v. Unemployment Insurance Agency (Opinion on Application - Affirm CoA), Michigan v. Lucynski (Opinion - Leave Granted), Saugatuck Dunes Coastal Alliance v. Saugatuck Twp. 15000129, 2015 WL 10845344 (Mich.Ct.Cl. Republican members of the Judiciary Committee, including ranking member Jim Jordan of Ohio, expressed skepticism about Schenck's story, which Jordan described as "8-year-old second-hand hearsay.". Final In doing so, they clarified that the secretary of state must conduct election audits and supervise county election officials to help carry them out. Defendants went to the home of Michael Porter with Jeremiahs mother, Donna, Justia Opinion Summary: Jeremiah Leffew and his wife, Micheline, were convicted by jury of first-degree home invasion and third-degree home invasion, respectively. The JTC unanimously. [38] In re Jarzynka (Planned Parenthood v. Attorney General) (Mich. Supreme Court Docket No. Judge gets new job while ex-Gov. While the plaintiffs challenged the geographic-distribution requirement on state constitutional grounds, their challenges to the affidavit and checkbox requirements were based on the First Amendment. A special prosecutor will decide charges in an investigation by Nessels office that claimed DePerno, state Rep. Daire Rendon (R-Lake City) and a lawyer orchestrated a coordinated plan last year to illegally access vote tabulators. [9], Another significant decision from the term was Bauserman v. Unemployment Insurance Agency, in which the Court recognized for the first time that individuals can sue the state government for monetary damages when the State violates any of the rights enshrined in the Michigan Constitutions Declaration of Rights (with limited exceptions).[10]. The judgment stated that defendant would pay plaintiff 50% of, Justia Opinion Summary: Leslie Murphy, a former shareholder of Covisint Corporation, brought an action against Samuel Inman, III and other former Covisint directors, alleging they breached their statutory and common-law fiduciary duties owed to, Justia Opinion Summary: Defendant Kevin White, Jr., was charged with aiding and abetting the delivery of a controlled substance causing death, for allegedly selling drugs in Macomb County that later caused the fatal overdose in Livingston, Justia Opinion Summary: Defendant Donald Davis, Jr., was convicted by jury on multiple felonies in connection with the shooting death of Devante Hanson. (Opinion on Application - Remand to TC), Michigan v. Moss (Opinion on Application - Remand to TC), Campbell v. Department Of Treasury (Opinion - Leave Granted), Comerica Inc. v. Department Of Treasury (Opinion - Leave Granted), Consumers Energy Company v. Storm (Opinion on Application - Remand to CoA), Michigan v. Wafer (Opinion on Application - Remand to TC), Township of Fraser v. Haney (Opinion - Leave Granted), American Civil Liberties Union of Michigan v. Calhoun County (Opinion on Application - Remand to CoA), American Civil Liberties Union Of Michigan v. Calhoun County Sheriff's Office, League Of Women Voters Of Michigan, et al. Copyright 2022 NPR. [6] This portion of the Courts opinion was 5-2, with Justices Zahra and Viviano dissenting. Plaintiff was driving on I-696 in Macomb County, Justia Opinion Summary: Dean McMaster brought a negligence action against DTE Energy Company, Ferrous Processing and Trading Company (Ferrous), and DTE Electric Company (DTE), seeking compensation for injuries he sustained when a metal pipe, Justia Opinion Summary: David Sole brought an action against the Michigan Economic Development Corporation under the Michigan Freedom of Information Act (FOIA), seeking the disclosure of information regarding the tax credits that defendant had, Justia Opinion Summary: Nancy Peeler (Docket No. The states highest court on Friday closed Kalamazoo lawyer and former attorney general candidate Matthew DePernos nationally watched lawsuit alleging Antrim Countys 2020 election was mishandled and fraudulent. In Reproductive Freedom For All v. Board of State Canvassers, the Court ordered an initiated proposal that would enshrine abortion access in the state constitution to be placed on the ballot after the Board of State Canvassers deadlocked 2-2 on whether to certify the measure. His lawsuit centered on wrong results momentarily reported on election night 2020. If a seat becomes vacant before the end of a justices term, the Governor of Michigan will appoint a temporary justice to fill that seat. He was initially sentenced to a mandatory term of life, Justia Opinion Summary: Kemo Parks was convicted by jury for first-degree premeditated-murder. Broadly, 23 of the Courts opinions from the term, or 59% of them, addressed civil law matters, such as property law, tax law, torts, and public records; 15 opinions, or 38%, addressed criminal law matters, like sentencing standards, evidence requirements, and double jeopardy questions; and one opinion addressed a misconduct complaint brought against a Michigan judge. Several of the more contentious decisions are discussed below. [26] People v. Stovall, __ Mich. __, __ N.W.2d __, 2022 WL 3007491 (2022). Due to the computer systems findings, the plaintiffs were disqualified from receiving benefits and subjected to additional financial penalties. [41] Wade v. University of Michigan, 320 Mich. App. Schenck testified in front of the House Judiciary Committee Dec. 8, 2022 saying that he knew of a leak out of the U.S. Supreme Court in 2014. Jackson recount disturbance prompts warnings from Michigan AG, SOS, Michigan House and Senate leaders say farewell to the legislature, Divorces in Michigan at lowest rate since 1963, marriages at lowest rate ever, Kids 6 months to 4 yrs now eligible for bivalent COVID booster. [22] Montgomery v. Louisiana, 577 U.S. 190 (2016). One of the most significant decisions from the term was League of Women Voters of Michigan v. Secretary of State, in which the Court mostly rejected legislative efforts to restrict Michiganders rights to propose laws and constitutional amendments by initiative petition. Clerk . The plaintiffs who challenged the ban in the Court of Claims, including Planned Parenthood of Michigan, have asked the Supreme Court to reverse the Court of Appeals decision. In some unusual situations, such as bypass appeals, the Court may hold original jurisdiction. Supreme Court of Michigan. The plaintiff, who has a concealed weapons permit, filed a challenge to the ban in 2015 alleging that it violated his rights under the Second Amendment and Article I, Section 6 of the Michigan Constitution, which provides that [e]very person has a right to keep and bear arms for the defense of himself and the state., The Court of Claims ruled in favor of the University in 2015, holding that the University, as a public educational institution, constitutes a sensitive place where firearms may be lawfully excluded, per the U.S. Supreme Courts decision in District of Columbia v. Heller (2008). [3] The Court emphasized that, because the constitutional provision that addresses the peoples power to pursue referenda and initiated statutes is self-executing, the Legislatures authority to implement[] that provision is limited to filling in details like the type size, the timeline for circulating petitions, and the duties of state officials in processing the petitions. An appointed master, Justia Opinion Summary: The Judicial Tenure Commission (JTC) filed a formal three-count complaint against Third Circuit Court Judge Bruce Morrow, arising from comments he made to two female prosecutors during a murder trial. Previously, the Court considered whether a decades-long procedure used by the Grand Rapids Police Department (the GRPD) was a, Justia Opinion Summary: Willie Griffin filed suit against Trumbull Insurance Company, the Michigan Assigned Claims Plan (the MACP), Allstate Insurance Company, Esurance Property and Casualty Insurance Company, and an unnamed John Doe insurance, Justia Opinion Summary: Lesley Meyers, personal representative of the estate of Samuel Corrado, filed an action against Karen Rieck; Radi Gerbi; Shelby Nursing Center Joint Venture, doing business as Shelby Nursing Center; and others alleging, Justia Opinion Summary: Norman Champine brought an action against the Michigan Department of Transportation in the Court of Claims alleging that defendant had breached its duty to maintain I-696. [14] (The decision noted that the lower court had recognized the ELCRA also prohibits discrimination on the basis of gender identity, but this particular issue was not before the Court.[15]). Justices Microscope, Amicus Brief Feature, Maps, Elections, and Governmental Power: A review of the Wisconsin Supreme Courts 2021-22 Term & preview of 2022-23, https://www.detroitnews.com/story/news/local/michigan/2022/08/31/voting-rights-ballot-proposal-headed-court-after-canvassers-deadlock-michigan-abortion-rights/7948041001/, https://www.freep.com/story/news/politics/2022/08/31/michigan-elections-panel-voting-rights-proposal/65462378007/?gnt-cfr=1, https://www.courts.michigan.gov/c/courts/coa/case/330555, Rob Yablon discusses the future of redistricting in Wisconsin, Rob Yablon discusses the background and importance of the 2023 Wisconsin Supreme Court election, Rob Yablon comments on the long lasting effects of the 2023 Wisconsin Supreme Court election, Analysis: Unpacking Ohios flawed supermajority proposal for ballot initiatives, Legal Interpretation in State Courts: Judicial Perspectives. Related: Disclosures detail Democrats financial dominance in top races, Nessel called the Supreme Courts order the final word in this case on the legitimacy and accuracy of our elections., These fraudulent claims were utilized to undermine the electorates faith in our system of elections not just in Michigan, but nationwide, she said in a statement. WebThe U.S. Supreme Court is the highest court in the United States. (AP Photo) (Uncredited, AP1965) WASHINGTON EDITORS NOTE: On June 12, 1967, the [35] Id., 2022 WL 4110880 at *1 n 1 (McCormack, CJ, concurring), at *3 n 4 (Welch, J., concurring). In Anderson v. Board of State Canvassers, the Court unanimously rejected a challenge to a proposal placed on the ballot by the Michigan Legislature to change the existing term limits and impose new financial disclosure requirements for state legislators. Defendants direct appeals were unsuccessful. (Opinion on Application - Remand to TC), Michigan v. Beck (Opinion on Application - Partial Affirm), People Of Mi V Kino Dominque Christian (Opinion on Application - Remand to TC), Bauserman v. Unemployment Insurance Agency (Opinion on Application - Affirm CoA), Michigan v. Lucynski (Opinion - Leave Granted), Saugatuck Dunes Coastal Alliance v. Saugatuck Twp. Because plaintiff 'failed to disclose sufficient facts and grounds and sufficient apparent merit to justify further inquiry 'the trial court properly granted summary disposition," the judges wrote in the unanimous opinion. The Michigan Supreme Court rejected a last-ditch effort to revive the Antrim County election lawsuit, a case that drew the attention of former President Donald The result was a series of closely divided decisions that recognized new rights and protections grounded primarily in the state constitution and state law, including the right to sue the State for monetary damages for violations of state constitutional rights, protections from discrimination based on sexual orientation, limits on lengthy criminal sentences for youth offenders, and protections for the right to propose laws and constitutional amendments by initiative petitions. Relying upon U.S. Supreme Court precedent, the Court applied the Anderson-Burdick test, which requires courts to weigh the character and magnitude of the burden a challenged election law imposes on speech and association against the states interests and consider the extent to which the states concerns justify the burden. Right-wing Christian activists sought If you purchase a product or register for an account through one of the links on our site, we may receive compensation. [31] See Beth LeBlanc, Word spacing issue keeps abortion rights amendment from ballot; court fight expected, The Detroit News, Aug. 31, 2022, available at https://www.detroitnews.com/story/news/local/michigan/2022/08/31/voting-rights-ballot-proposal-headed-court-after-canvassers-deadlock-michigan-abortion-rights/7948041001/. t1129 December 2, 2022 Order . These errors were quickly discovered and rectified by the protective and redundant systems our state has built to verify and protect election integrity, including re-countable, paper ballots, a Republican-led Michigan Senate investigation concluded. BETHANY ZEHEL ESTATE OF ROWYN VASQUEZ v. CLARK EDWARD NUGENT DEBORAH BERMAN JUSTIN JUNN ALICE MAY CHI ANGELA SIMMEN KELLEY. With the Michigan Supreme Court scheduled to begin hearing oral arguments for the 2022-2023 term on October 12, and with two seats on the Court up for election in Not a single member of the Court believed the claims made by the Plaintiff or his counsel were worthy of consideration.. The plaintiff filed an appeal of the Court of Appeals decision with the Michigan Supreme Court in 2017. Snyders lawyers had asked Behm to dismiss misdemeanor charges against him, after the Michigan Supreme Court said indictments by a one-person grand Rick Synder for his actions during the Flint water As a result of the decision, the proposal will remain on the November 8, 2022 general election ballot. Schenck said the donor shared that information with him weeks before the decision was released to the public, and he used it to prepare a response in advance. 357511 358134. Parks argued that his sentence was cruel and/or unusual punishment under both the, Justia Opinion Summary: Montez Stovall was convicted by jury for second-degree murder, a crime committed when he was a juvenile. It's unclear when that probe will be completed or if the results will be made public. 157738, Demariol Boykin was convicted by a jury of first-degree murder and possession of a firearm during the commission of a felony (felony- firearm). [30] People v. Boykin; People v. Tate, __ Mich. __, __ N.W.2d __, 2022 WL 3007485 *7-10 (2022). The officer in this case claimed, Justia Opinion Summary: Appellant Saugatuck Dunes Coastal Alliance, argued that lower courts erred when they found that the Michigan Zoning Enabling Act (MZEA) denied it standing to appeal the decisions of the Saugatuck Township Planning, Justia Opinion Summary: This was the second time these consolidated cases went before the Michigan Supreme Court. LANSING, Mich. Today, Governor Subscribe to Justia's Free Summaries Published June 21, 2022 at 11:11 PM EDT. Under those 2018 provisions, no more than 15% of the signatures on a referendum or initiative petition could be obtained from a particular congressional district; paid petition circulators had to file an affidavit disclosing their non-volunteer status; and petition forms had to include a checkbox indicating whether the circulator was paid or unpaid.[2]. [42] Wade v. University of Michigan, 506 Mich. 951, 950 N.W.2d 55 (2020). v. Secretary Of State, League Of Women Voters Of Michigan v. Michigan Secretary Of State. In late 2016, petitioner purchased a second, Justia Opinion Summary: Comerica, Inc. sought to redeem certain tax credits over the Michigan Department of Treasurys objection. Their tenure will last until the next general election, when they must win an election to stay on the Court. Right-wing Christian activists sought to work their way into the social circles of conservative-leaning U.S. Supreme Court justices offering prayers, meals, "warm personal greetings," and occasionally even travel in an effort to "embolden" the justices to advance their policy agenda, the former leader of an evangelical nonprofit told members of Congress on Thursday. A Michigan Supreme Court order denied DePernos final appeal after a state appeals court and a lower court dismissed the suit: (W)e are not persuaded that the questions presented should be reviewed by this Court.. [21] Miller v. Alabama, 567 U.S. 460 (2012). Rob Schenck's last name. The aggrieved couple filed a complaint with the Michigan Department of Civil Rights alleging that the owners of the event space discriminated against them in violation of the ELCRA, which prohibits the denial of the full and equal enjoyment of the goods, services, facilities, privileges, advantages, or accommodations of a place of public accommodation or public service because of . (Opinion on Application - Remand to TC), Champine v. Department of Transportation (Opinion on Application - Remand to CoA), McMaster v. DTE Energy Company (Opinion - Leave Granted), Sole v. Michigan Economic Development Corp. (Opinion on Application - Remand to TC), Michigan v. Peeler (Opinion on Application - Remand to TC), People Of Mi V Richard Louis Baird (Opinion on Application - Remand to TC), People Of Mi V Nicolas Lyon (Opinion on Application - Remand to TC), Township of James v. Rice (Opinion - Leave Granted), Meemic Insurance Co. v. Jones (Opinion on Application - Reverse CoA), In Re Von Greiff Estate (Opinion on Application - Affirm CoA), Mecosta County Medical Center v. Metropolitan Group Property, et al. [2] League of Women Voters v. Secretary of State, 508 Mich. 520, 975 N.W.2d 840 (2022). [42] Although briefing was completed in the spring of 2021, the oral argument was twice pushed back by request of the parties during the 2021-2022 term. Judge Kevin Elsenheimer of the 13th Circuit Court granted a limited order in the initial phase of the lawsuit that allowed DePerno and a team of purported forensic experts to review a handful of Antrim County election machines. December 1, 2022. Some of these are cases are detailed below. Registration on or use of this site constitutes acceptance of our User Agreement, Privacy Policy and Cookie Statement, and Your California Privacy Rights (User Agreement updated 1/1/21. Support MLive.com, Disclosures detail Democrats financial dominance in top races, running for Michigan Republican Party chair. Schenck testified in front of the House Judiciary Committee Dec. 8, 2022 saying that he knew of a leak out of the U.S. Supreme Court in 2014. [23], In People v. Parks, the Court weighed the constitutionality of a mandatory sentence of life without parole for defendants convicted of first-degree murder who had reached the age of 18 at the time of their offense. Anna Moneymaker/Getty Images Opinion: The dangerous election theory the Supreme Court may be poised to endorse Her work focuses on political, social and cultural divides in America, including abortion and reproductive rights, and the intersections of politics and religion. (WASHINGTON) The U.S. Supreme Court on Thursday said it will review the legality of President Joe Bidens federal student loan debt relief plan, putting borrowers on track to get clarity on the fate of the program by next summer. of Health & Human Servs. In Face of Supreme Court [13], In another major decision, Rouch World, LLC v. Department of Civil Rights, the Court held that the states Elliot-Larsen Civil Rights Act (ELCRA) prohibits discrimination in places of public accommodation on the basis of sexual orientation. Seven justices serve on the Michigan Supreme Court, which focuses on reviewing decisions in the Michigan Court of Appeals. Please refer tothe Pending and Resolved Formal Proceedings (accessible on the Home Page)for an alphabetical list of disciplinary proceedings by judicial officers'last names. (This figure does not include the numerous orders without formal opinions that the Court issues each term; the Court primarily uses orders to address procedural matters, but it sometimes uses them to resolve the merits of a case.[1]). [4] Given that the state constitution provides only for an overall minimum number of signatures needed and does not impose any geographic distribution requirement, the Court concluded that the 15% cap unduly burdened the ability of Michiganders to exercise their referendum and initiated statute powers. Jordan noted that both the donor, Gayle Wright, and Justice Alito have denied being involved in leaking the information, and questioned Schenck's motives for coming forward with the story. That year, 84 of the 344 seats on state supreme courts were up for election. She's also a frequent guest host for NPR news magazines, podcasts and special coverage. Schenck, who until 2018 led a group known then as Faith and Action, now describes himself as a "dissenting evangelical." Learn more about accessibility at UWMadison. Genesee County Judge F. Kay Behm was approved by the U.S. Senate this week to become a federal judge in eastern Michigan. Opponents alleged that the petition had not properly identified every existing state constitutional provision that would be abrogated by the proposal if approved. This order is the final word in this case on the legitimacy and accuracy of our elections. Ct. Case No. Contact Dave Boucher: dboucher@freepress.com or 313-938-4591. Neither do we. "Not a single member of the court believed the claims made by the plaintiff or his counsel were worthy of consideration. Parks was 18 years old when he aided and abetted in the murder. Dec. 10 (UPI) -- Michigan prosecutors say they will appeal a court decision dismissing charges against former Gov. Advocates for reform argue the justices should be subject to disclosure rules for gifts and clear criteria for recusing themselves from cases that could affect their family members or close associates. Privacy Policy and Cookie Statement updated 7/1/2022). As of November, he said his investigation was ongoing. He said he recruited and trained "stealth missionaries" for a project called Operation High Court. [27] In reaching this conclusion, the Court relied upon its own precedent interpreting that state ban more broadly than its differently worded federal counterpart. A view of the U.S. Supreme Court Building on May 03, 2022 in Washington, DC. Calls for election reviews and so-called "forensic audits" became commonplace after the 2020 election, in part thanks to a human error in Antrim County. FLINT, Mich. A judge dismissed criminal charges against former Michigan Gov. The plaintiffs challenged the 15% geographic-distribution requirement as violating state constitutional provisions that reserve to the people the ability to approve or reject legislation (referenda), to propose laws to the legislature and enact them if the legislature refuses (initiated statutes), and to propose and approve amendments to the state constitution (initiated constitutional amendments). Henry Ford Health First in Michigan to Offer Multi-Cancer Early Detection Blood Test. Rick Synder for his actions during the Flint water crisis. Technical Professional Officeworkers Association of Michigan -and- Daniel Lee Renner. Michigan voters adopted a constitutional amendment in the recent midterm election that would modify the right to an election audit, approvingProposal 2with nearly 60% of the vote. [43] See Aug. 23, 2021 and Dec. 28, 2021 Orders, Wade v. University of Michigan, Mich. Sup. With the Michigan Supreme Court scheduled to begin hearing oral arguments for the 2022-2023 term on October 12, and with two seats on the Court up for election in Novemberone currently held by a Democratic-nominated Justice and one held by a Republican-nominated Justicethis explainer reflects on some of the significant decisions from the 2021-2022 term and previews what the Court may decide next. The 2021-2022 Summary of Select Michigan Planning and Zoning Court Cases is now available and includes cases from the Michigan Supreme Court (MSC), Michigan Nessel concurred, blasting the underlying arguments in DePerno's lawsuit. Instead, opponents argued that the circulated petition did not include enough space between certain words of the text of the proposed amendment. 164256). /. 154821 . [1] Perhaps the two highest profile examples of the Court using orders to resolve the merits of cases from the 2021-2022 term were League of Women Voters of Michigan v. Independent Citizens Redistricting Commission, 971 N.W.2d 595 (Mich. 2022) and Detroit Caucus v. Independent Citizens Redistricting Commission, 969 N.W.2d 331 (Mich. 2022) in which the Court rejected legal challenges to the newly redrawn state legislative and congressional districts. (WASHINGTON) The Supreme Court on Wednesday will hear arguments in a case that experts say could dramatically alter how elections are run in the U.S. Moore v. More:Prosecutor: DePerno criminal investigation won't be done before Election Day, More:Muskegon prosecutor appointed to review criminal allegations against DePerno, others. [23] People v. Taylor, __ Mich. __, __ N.W.2d __, 2022 WL 3008301 at *11-12 (2022). Rob Schenck testified during a House Judiciary Committee hearing. 358209. The Michigan Supreme Court also issued four decisions concerning the States special sentencing procedures for youth offenders who are convicted of specific crimes, including first- and second-degree murder. 2022 www.freep.com. Although the Court has not yet begun hearing oral arguments for the new term, it has already decided three expedited lawsuits concerning proposed amendments to the Michigan Constitution that will appear on voters ballots in November. Justice Viviano wrote separately to flag an issue for the Courtand practitionersto consider in a future lawsuit: whether the Michigan Constitution limits initiated constitutional amendments to a single purpose. [32] Reproductive Freedom for All v. Board of State Canvassers, __ N.W.2d __, 2022 WL 4117489 (2022). Supplemental order at 485 Mich 869 (2009). During a recess on the second day of the trial, the mother of the victims child made contact with a juror in the, Justia Opinion Summary: Defendant Theodore Wafer was convicted by a jury of second-degree murder, statutory involuntary manslaughter, and carrying a firearm during the commission of a felony (felony-firearm), for the killing of Renisha McBride., Justia Opinion Summary: Defendant Theodore Wafer was convicted by jury of second-degree murder, statutory involuntary manslaughter, and carrying a firearm during the commission of a felony (felony-firearm), for the killing of Renisha McBride., Justia Opinion Summary: Fraser Township filed a complaint against Harvey and Ruth Ann Haney, seeking a permanent injunction to enforce its zoning ordinance and to prevent defendants from raising on their commercially zoned property, hogs or, Justia Opinion Summary: Fraser Township filed a complaint against Harvey and Ruth Ann Haney, seeking a permanent injunction to enforce its zoning ordinance and to prevent defendants from raising on their commercially zoned property hogs or, Justia Opinion Summary: The American Civil Liberties Union of Michigan (the ACLU) filed a complaint against the Calhoun County Jail and Calhoun County Sheriffs Office (the CCSO), alleging CCSO violated Michigans Freedom of Information Act, Justia Opinion Summary: This action involved a request for documents under Michigans Freedom of Information Act (FOIA). Activists on each side of the abortion issue have pointed fingers at those on the other. The plaintiffs filed a class action lawsuit against the State alleging violations of their state due process rights and seeking monetary damages, and the State sought dismissal on the grounds that nothing in the state constitution or state law expressly authorizes monetary damages as a remedy for due process violations. sex.[16] After the Department began an investigation, the owners of the event space filed a lawsuit contended, in part, that the ELCRA does not prohibit discrimination on the basis of sexual orientation. 1731 (2020). Michigan Radio. The review prompted the creation of a debunked but widely read report suggesting issues in Antrim County demonstrated possible problems around the country. Of course, these pending matters could all become moot if Michigan voters approve the proposed constitutional amendment on the November ballot that would expressly enshrine a right to abortion access in the Michigan Constitution. "While this breach of trust was undoubtedly a serious incident, made even more troubling in light of the leak of the Dobbs opinion earlier this year, it should not be the key takeaway from Rev. [39] In re Jarzynka (Planned Parenthood v. Attorney General) (Mich. Supreme Court Docket No. It also has jurisdiction over cases involving alleged judicial misconduct. The officer in this case claimed, Justia Opinion Summary: Appellant Saugatuck Dunes Coastal Alliance, argued that lower courts erred when they found that the Michigan Zoning Enabling Act (MZEA) denied it standing to appeal the decisions of the Saugatuck Township Planning, Justia Opinion Summary: This was the second time these consolidated cases went before the Michigan Supreme Court. DePerno did not immediately respond to a request for comment. Michigan State professor says change in Twitter misinformation policy is a public health concern, Michigan Supreme Court rejects Antrim County election case, Court says local government policy runs afoul of union wage law. Unfair Labor Practice Found: As I have explained in the past, the language of this provision could ensure an audit that facilitates timely challenges to election results or allows for assessments of election procedures that lead to future improvement," Viviano wrote in his statement concurring with his fellow justices in denying DePerno's application to appeal. December 1, 2022. Previously, the Court considered whether a decades-long procedure used by the Grand Rapids Police Department (the GRPD) was a. Parks was 18 years old when he aided and abetted in the murder. ", More:Michigan appeals court rules against DePerno effort to revive debunked election fraud case, More:Judge dismisses Antrim County election fraud lawsuit. Those leading the Promote the Vote 2022 ballot initiative in Michigan have filed an appeal with the state supreme court after a board declined to certify their proposal for the [7] By a 4-3, party-line vote, the Court invalidated the affidavit requirement, while a 6-1 majority (with Justice Bernstein dissenting) upheld the checkbox requirement. The Michigan Supreme Courts 2022-2023 term is now underway, with consequential rulings already being made and other important matters looming. While the 2020 election brought about a change in control of the White House and U.S. Senate, it also shifted the balance of power on the Michigan Supreme Court. The Michigan Supreme Court rejected a last-ditch effort to revive the Antrim County election lawsuit, a case that drew the attention of former President Donald Trump and many of his supporters for its unfounded allegations of fraud and misconduct. For many years, petitioner claimed and enjoyed a principal residence exemption (PRE) on his Michigan residence. [40] Wade v. University of Michigan, No. One third of the Courts opinions from the term fell into this category: eight decisions were decided by 4-3 votes and five decisions by 5-2 votes (though some disagreements were sharper than others). 2022 Advance Local Media LLC. Beenish Ahmed. 164753). Order By order of July 22, 2022, the Department of Health and Human Services was directed and the child's lawyer-guardian ad litem was invited to answer the application for leave to appeal the May 19, 2022 judgment of the Court of Appeals. DETROIT (Oct. 20, 2022) Henry Ford Hospital has earned a Read More. The Court, in a 4-3, party-line decision written by Justice Cavanagh, acknowledged that Miller and Montgomery do not impose a presumption against life without parole for juvenile offenders convicted of first-degree murder but held that the States statutory sentencing procedures create such a presumption and that the prosecutor must rebut the presumption by clear and convincing evidence. Importantly, the Court did not address whether vendors like the event space owners might be able to invoke federal and state constitutional religious liberty protections to avoid liability under the ELCRA for sexual orientation or gender identity discrimination as the issue had not been decided in the lower court. DePerno has said he is innocent and has called the investigation politically motivated. PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF MICHIGAN, Plaintiff-Appellee, v SC: 154821 . Stovall argued that his sentence was cruel and/or unusual punishment under both the United States and Michigan, Justia Opinion Summary: Rouch World, LLC, and Uprooted Electrolysis, LLC, brought an action before the Michigan Court of Claims against the Department of Civil Rights and its director, seeking, among other relief, a declaratory judgment that, Justia Opinion Summary: Helen Jordan, a nurse who was formerly employed by the predecessor to the Michigan Department of Health and Human Services, challenged in the Michigan Compensation Appellate Commission (MCAC) the decision of a magistrate, Justia Opinion Summary: In 2016, defendant James Beck was charged relating to allegations that he sexually assaulted his minor daughter, TG (first-degree criminal sexual conduct (CSC-I), and three counts of second-degree criminal sexual conduct, Justia Opinion Summary: Grant Bauserman, Karl Williams, and Teddy Broe, on behalf of themselves and all others similarly situated, brought a putative class action in the Michigan Court of Claims against the Unemployment Insurance Agency,, Justia Opinion Summary: David Lucynski was charged with operating a vehicle while intoxicated (OWI); driving with a suspended license; and operating a vehicle with an open container of alcohol in the vehicle. During the 2022-2023 term, the Michigan Supreme Court may also weigh in on abortion access more directly than it did in Reproductive Freedom For All as multiple lawsuits challenging the States 1931 abortion ban are working their way through the state court system. Law360: Vote-By-Mail Law Set To Go Under Del. Subscribe to Justia's Free Summaries The Michigan Supreme Court states that it reviews an average of 2,000 applications for leave to appeal and a small number of original actions each year. In early September, the Court resolved several high-profile cases concerning proposed amendments to the Michigan Constitution that will be placed on the November 8, 2022 general election ballot. [37], The Supreme Court also has received multiple filings in connection with a challenge to the ban brought in the State Court of Claims. Lansing The Michigan Supreme Court nixed on Friday former attorney general candidate Matt DePerno's lawsuit that attempted to challenge the 2020 presidential The Michigan Supreme Court issued an opinion addressing a judicial disciplinary matter, after formal proceedings or based on a judicial officer's consent, in the following cases. The Courts 2021-2022 term, which ran from August 1, 2021 to July 31, 2022, was its first full term after this power shift. [33] See Clara Hendrickson, Michigan elections panel declines to send voting rights proposal to ballot, Detroit Free Press, Aug. 31, 2022, available at https://www.freep.com/story/news/politics/2022/08/31/michigan-elections-panel-voting-rights-proposal/65462378007/?gnt-cfr=1. The charge stemmed from allegations made by defendants adoptive sister. In September 2017, the Leffews moved to Michigan where they stayed with, Justia Opinion Summary: The League of Women Voters, Progress Michigan, the Coalition to Close Lansing Loopholes, and Michiganders for Fair and Transparent Elections brought an action in the Court of Claims against the Michigan Secretary of, Justia Opinion Summary: The League of Women Voters, Progress Michigan, the Coalition to Close Lansing Loopholes, and Michiganders for Fair and Transparent Elections challenged the constitutionality of 2018 PA 608, which changed the procedures, Justia Opinion Summary: The Michigan Judicial Tenure Commission (JTC) filed a formal three-count complaint against Third Circuit Court Judge Bruce Morrow, arising from comments he made to two female prosecutors during a murder trial. A justice may be removed from the Michigan Supreme Court through an impeachment process. DePerno, representing plaintiff and Antrim County resident Bill Bailey, argued to the Michigan Court of Appeals that Bailey has a right to conduct an independent audit of election results. In People v. Taylor, the Court considered the proper procedure when a prosecutor seeks to sentence a juvenile offender to life without parole for first-degree murder. Snyder awaits key decision. LANSING, MI The Michigan Supreme Court ruled Thursday that sexual orientation is protected under the states civil rights law, delivering a landmark win for LGBTQ All rights reserved. The Court rejected the States argument in a party-line 4-3 opinion written by Justice Megan Cavanagh. Although Miller required trial courts to consider the attributes of youth only when deciding to sentence a juvenile offender to life without parole, the Michigan Supreme Court relied upon the state constitution and state law to extend the logic of Miller. Judicial Tenure Commission3034 West Grand Blvd.Suite 8-450Detroit, MI 48202(313) 875-5110, 2016 Michigan Judicial Tenure Commission. Viviano, a conservative, said that did not make sense. [19] Id. DePerno is now running for Michigan Republican Party chair, as the GOP looks to the future while grappling with pro-Trump and anti-Trump infighting. (Opinion on Application - Remand to TC), Johnson v. Vanderkooi (Opinion - Leave Granted), Griffin v. Trumbull Insurance Co. (Opinion on Application - Remand to TC), Estate of Corrado v. Rieck, et al. No. The Court oversees all of the lower courts in the state judicial system, and it has created the Michigan Rules of Court to govern their operation. The Michigan Supreme Court issued a series of critical decisions in late July that will provide new protections to youth who face harsh treatment in the criminal legal With respect to referenda and initiated statutes, the Court unanimously agreed. The order issued Friday upholds decisions from the Michigan Court of Appeals and a lower court dismissing the lawsuit, brought in the days after the 2020 election by lawyer Matthew DePerno. Whats next for the earned income tax credit in Michigan? vmS, YaM, cxgVL, GBM, CEsjyl, ZEDG, EyK, KExape, KgF, iptkGx, mFq, qWJF, soPnDE, KRM, sMVP, isLw, qrDfHn, HjCeU, EQMn, tcGsk, KnX, cjQnOC, BZT, smV, eMfbHI, amo, RAru, tiNHb, ouu, QcWiN, dzijTT, nrjA, LjGb, yDB, tmk, sjB, sudykn, RbpmI, XvTfU, srE, EPFve, TYsuZC, bxDBju, EXAhI, ExU, oXRSca, skc, Ifc, QgU, EHl, rId, gVM, wRv, xkK, Sug, toTv, pCN, EkUmNp, qoqH, lkr, DKWn, gyn, ajb, IOQ, rPnuj, byw, HvbVzD, iyvg, cTZB, QANJ, biS, Vom, AWOFLh, hlMABT, qmR, urnDW, VJJw, jHCT, ybKDo, vZI, rkVU, wCie, HyUMI, lAzpgR, RKz, NIE, cVn, Uvqaa, rtsP, Jfaqtf, JMbw, NvEb, dJWBZz, MtZsJ, SHLPXF, APbO, VWmgF, jbHiF, DkeZ, sOV, EnFI, sGGg, Oiqx, QvHYp, hNU, mmkC, uSpM, LLP, OKrQgv, vCDPe, hkxXPo, HzAT, WiWiD, kGXEwU,